Hopewell Chin’ono Raises Questions Over ‘Unrecovered Black Box’ in Wicknell Chivayo Helicopter Crash Report

Hopewell Chin’ono Raises Questions Over ‘Unrecovered Black Box’ in Wicknell Chivayo Helicopter Crash Report

Journalist Hopewell Chin’ono has raised questions over inconsistencies surrounding the black box from the helicopter that crashed at Kudenga Farm, killing businessman Wicknell Chivayo and four other people.

Chin’ono questioned how the recorder could have been presumed destroyed despite the aircraft coming down in an open field, arguing that the preliminary investigation report has not adequately explained what happened to the crash-protected device.

His concerns follow the release of a preliminary report by the Air Accidents and Incidents Investigation Department of the Ministry of Transport and Infrastructural Development, which disclosed that the cockpit voice recorder (CVR) had not been recovered.

Also Read: Wicknell Chivayo Helicopter Crash: Preliminary Report Rules Out Mid-Air Explosion, Reveals What Happened

Chin’ono Questions Contradictory Statements Over Black Box

In a Facebook post, Chin’ono highlighted what he described as inconsistencies between earlier statements from aviation authorities and findings contained in the preliminary report.

He noted that the Civil Aviation Authority of Zimbabwe (CAAZ) had initially indicated that an intact recorder was recovered from the crash site.

However, the subsequent investigation report stated that the cockpit voice recorder was not found and was presumed to have been destroyed.

Chin’ono questioned why the public had initially been told that the device had been recovered when investigators were now reporting that it was missing.

He argued that recovering the black box could have helped investigators establish what happened during the helicopter’s final moments, including whether there were unusual sounds or communications indicating an explosion.

The report instead identified the accident as an unintended flight into instrument meteorological conditions (IMC), followed by controlled flight into terrain (CFIT).

This classification points to the aircraft entering weather conditions that made it difficult for the pilots to maintain visual contact with their surroundings before hitting the ground.

However, investigators have indicated that further analysis is required before the probable cause of the crash can be established.

Chin’ono Questions Why Crash-Protected Recorder Was Not Recovered

A major part of Chin’ono’s concerns centres on the ability of cockpit voice recorders to withstand severe accidents.

He explained that the devices contain specially protected memory units designed to survive extreme impact forces, crushing pressure and intense heat.

He cited international safety standards requiring crash-protected recording units to withstand temperatures of up to 1,100 degrees Celsius for at least 30 minutes, among other demanding conditions.

Chin’ono also referred to the recovery of the recorders from Air France Flight 447, which remained underwater at a depth of approximately 3,900 metres for nearly two years before being retrieved with their data successfully recovered.

Against this background, he questioned whether the fire at Kudenga Farm was sufficient to destroy the recorder.

He acknowledged that the post-crash fire could technically have damaged the device but argued that the information contained in the preliminary report did not conclusively establish that this had happened.

The report described the wreckage as being scattered across an area measuring approximately 170 metres by 75 metres, with the largest sections, including the upper fuselage and engines, suffering extensive fire damage.

Chin’ono said investigators should establish the type of recorder installed on the helicopter, where it was positioned and what physical evidence supports the conclusion that it was destroyed.

Chin’ono Calls for Answers in Final Investigation Report

Chin’ono argued that the outstanding questions should be addressed in the final investigation report, particularly the circumstances surrounding the missing cockpit voice recorder.

He said investigators needed to establish whether the recorder was a genuine crash-protected unit, whether it was thrown clear of the aircraft during impact or whether it was destroyed by the post-crash fire.

He warned that leaving these issues unexplained could fuel speculation about the circumstances surrounding the fatal crash.

The post Hopewell Chin’ono Raises Questions Over ‘Unrecovered Black Box’ in Wicknell Chivayo Helicopter Crash Report appeared first on iHarare News.